Thursday, September 5, 2019

Lawrence Kohlberg's model of ethics in 6 stages

The most powerful idea/concept that I used while watching the "Roll Red Roll: Steubenville" documentary was Lawrence Kohlberg’s model which focuses on the 6 stages of increasing depth of reasoning when contemplating best ethical practices. 
In short, Lawrence Kohlberg’s model theorizes that the lowest stage of ethics is when individuals make moral decisions on the basis of what is best for themselves without regard for the needs or feelings of others. These people only obey rules only if established by more powerful individuals, and disobey when they can do so without being caught. Throughout the film, I observed many individuals, besides the perpetrators, who decided to keep vital information to themselves until pressured by a more powerful force, such as, the police. 
On the other end of the spectrum, there lay the universal ethical principle where individuals adhere to a small number of abstract, universal principles that transcend specific concrete rules. These people answer to an inner conscience and may break rules that violate their own ethical principles.
I also considered Carol Gilligan’s orthogonal axis of ethical care. Her axis of ethical care states that an obligation of care rests on the understanding of relationships as a response to another in terms of their special needs. It focuses on the moral value of being empathetic toward those dearly beloved persons with whom we have special and valuable relationships and the moral importance of responding to such persons as unique individuals with characteristics that require custom-crafted responses to them that we do not normally extend to others. 
I observed how each individual in the film responded to the situation ethically and within their best ability, and then determined the differences between being positively moral or ethical, or negatively moral or ethical.

Below, here is a visual of Lawrence Kohlberg's model of ethics.





Wednesday, September 4, 2019

Rape Culture



As seen in the Steubenville case, many places around the world are perfectly ok with rape, and even go so far as to normalize it. In Ohio, where this case takes place, you can already begin to see the trend of talking about rape over social media such as Twitter. Mainly the boys, where saying crude things about the victim, Jane, among many other girls. It became completely normal to talk about rape like a running gag- as if it wasn't ruining girls lives. Even Jane's "friends" were saying this such as, "she should take responsibility for going to the party", and "she should've taken responsibility for drinking". This is an example of victim-blaming. By that logic, every girl at that party deserved to get raped, and it would be their fault because they wanted to show up and drink. It is culture to talk about rape as if the girls deserved it because of rumors of her just being at a slut or a whore. The boys even went so far as to make videos talking about how they raped her. They even took photos of her passed out and shared it with their friends to further dehumanize her.



This isn't just the case in Steubenville Ohio, we can find rape culture in many parts of the world. Rape culture can be defined as blaming the victim, defending the perpetrator, sexually explicit jokes that normalize rape, and therefore forcing girls to tolerate sexual harassment. Not to say that men aren't affected by rape, although 90% of rape is done to females. Young girls especially (highschool, college-age) are being targeted by these perpetrators. When someone grows up in rape culture they tolerate sexual harassment, but that does not mean they agree to rape. It is common for a perpetrator to believe that if the girl is tolerating me sexually dehumanizing her, that must mean she wants to have sex. This mindset is the core of rape culture, and it must be stopped.


Sources:
https://www.marshall.edu/wcenter/sexual-assault/rape-culture/
https://www.rainn.org/statistics/victims-sexual-violence
https://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2013/03/steubenville-victim-testimony/317302/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steubenville_High_School_rape_case

Nick Hillary

In “Who Killed Garrett Phillips?" has shown me how many people all over the world can be blamed of a crime they didn't do, and how racism is still happening till this day our community hasn't changed in how they view others which is something very heart breaking. The documentary has really changed my perspective in other people and specially Caucasian individuals that just like to blame colored individuals.




"Security Theater" and Liquid Bombs


      In our discussion about safety versus personal liberty, we discussed the restrictions and regulations we experience while going through airport security. One of these included the restrictions on liquids on flights. The reason why airport security routinely checks liquids can be traced to the American and British Operation Overt, involving men who smuggled liquid explosives on planes. The leader, the Abdulla Ahmed Ali, was compelled by the appalling conditions of Afghanistan refugee camps he witnessed after leaving the UK. These men then made explosive devices of hydrogen peroxide and batteries using the internet. The explosives were then brought on planes, in order to spread their message against what they perceived as unjust foreign policy. These were uncovered when he returned home with the soft drink explosives. Had his plan worked, there could have been disastrous consequences for passengers. The Bojinka Plot was another instigator that occurred much earlier. Ramzi Yousef used liquid explosives in a Philippine Airline flight going to Tokyo. One person was killed in the incident. 

     The restrictions put in place by the TSA (3.4 ounces per person) are meant to prevent such attacks from becoming any worse. The size prevents any explosive liquid that a container might contain from doing any critical damage to the flight.

     While all of this suggests that this restriction is relatively reasonable, it begs the question of whether these ‘safety precautions’ are actually effective rather than just “security theater”. Restricting liberty in favor of safety can be warranted, but that still requires that it actually keep us safe. According to the Washington Post, the body-scanners meant to detect the carrying of the explosives on board are not effective. Although liquids are banned, they can still be smuggled in, so what’s the point exactly? There’s nothing stopping terrorists from trying to smuggle in liquids again and again on board because the policy does not have any consequences for those who violate it. At most, the bottle will be thrown away or confiscated. How can this help protect us if it wastes money one something that does not really work? There are other policies that are meant to scare off amateurs, and those who really want to cause damage can continue to try until the system fumbles. There are plenty of other things that have caused more deaths than terrorism: heart disease, cancer, stroke, cars; so why are we so caught up with checking baggage? If we are going to restrict our liberties and waste our time, there should be legitimate and effective reasons. Security clearance should protect rather than lull us into a false sense of security.


Sources
http://mentalfloss.com/article/565368/tsa-airport-liquids-rule-water-bottles-explained 

Tuesday, September 3, 2019

Should the 2nd Amendment be Re-Looked at?

This is something we briefly touched on in class today, so I would like to dive a little deeper into this issue here. The Second Amendment of the United States Bill of Rights states, "A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed." With evolving times, how should we interpret this today? Some people believe it should be changed, while others believe that what is stated is set in stone. Now as Mr. Stewart said, "Arms" is a very broad term. That being said, I would like to specifically focus on fire arms.

Image result for 2nd amendment debate

Fire Arms today are very different than they were almost 250 years ago when the Bill of Rights was written. At the time the idea of a "deadly rifle" was a single shot gun that took a well trained soldier anywhere from 10-15 seconds to load, meaning he was firing around 4-5 rounds per minute. Compare that to today where we have a wide range of fire arms, all of which can be deadly, with guns that can fire 60 rounds per minute.

With all of the mass shootings that have happened recently I think it is time to step in and ask the major question that has divided our country for many years now. Was this law written to accommodate modern day guns?

Some would argue that it doesn't matter if it was meant to accommodate modern guns, because as gun technology develops, people need the newer guns to protect themselves from them. A common counter to this though is that if all guns are banned, then you will not need the newer gun to protect yourself because you wont be in danger of anyone having a gun to put you in danger in the first place.

This is were I believe we have to go back to the context of this law being written. Being in 1793, the United States was still weak. In fear of another great power attacking, it made sense that the people be armed since they were the ones that made up their state Militias. It was also thought that if the government turned tyrannical, the states could use their Militias to rise up and reinstate democracy.

Now that we are way beyond this stage in our history and in no fear of being attacked by a super power, or having our government turn against us and rule in tyranny, does this law really continue to be valid or do we need to look at it again and maybe adjust some of its parameters?

Sources:
https://www.constituteproject.org/constitution/United_States_of_America_1992

Fire in a Theater— Is There More to this Inflammatory Story?

“...Free speech would not protect a man in falsely shouting fire in a theater and causing a panic.”
As Justice Oliver Holmes summed up in U.S. vs. Schenk, there are limitations on free speech. In class we discussed the difference between civil liberties and civil rights, free speech being one of the former. While it sets limits to what is considered to be free speech, where exactly does this quote come from?
U.S. vs. Schenk occurred during 1919, when WWI was in swing. It had nothing to do with a theater or fire for the matter. Rather, it involved the Espionage Act of 1917 that was in place during the time. The act outlawed the undermining of military efforts or enlisting. Two socialists, including the secretary of the Socialist Party Charles Schenck, were charged with breaching the act by distributing pamphlets that encouraged people to go against the draft. The men responded with an appeal on the grounds of the First Amendment. The court overruled the appeal, stating that it was within their authority due to the fact that there was a war. Holmes concluded that if the words constituted a threat to the safety of others, it was not protected by the Bill of Rights. It was then that he brought up the quote in dictum. Schenk was sentenced to a decade in prison.
Then came Brandenburg vs. Ohio. The year was 1969, and Clarence Brandenburg stood before the Warren Court (probably best known for its judicial activism). As a leader of the KKK, he challenged Ohio law outlawing speech that encouraged violence and illegal behavior. Unlike the previous court case, the court found that the speech was not likely and did not directly incite violence amongst people. The Warren Court overturned the law and ruled in favor of Brandenburg. Thus, the ruling of Schenk was by all means overturned, as protesting the draft was not a call for violence. In fact, the Schneck and his partner had been encouraging pacifist ideas. 
All of this points to the conclusion that this quote, though well known, it is not the best one to look to in regards to the limits of free speech. As it is with most things, what was relevant one hundred years ago might no longer be true today.


Sources

Sunday, September 1, 2019

Women-Only Train Cars


Groping on public transportation is an issue across the globe.  During rush hour
when people are packed so so close together that you can raise both feet from
the floor and remain upright, it is easy for a hand to slip where it shouldn’t be.
Because it’s so crowded, women cannot escape, and in countries like Japan
where politeness governs society, they find it hard to report sexual harassment.
As a result, commuter harassers often do not face any consequences, and the
problem continues to grow.  Women and girls are not only being harassed, but
they are also being gang-raped and murdered on public transportation in
Thailand and India.


To combat this, many countries such as Brazil, Japan, Mexico, Egypt, India,
Thailand, and Nepal have been implementing women-only train cars.  On these
train cars, women report feeling “free from the male stares and aggressions that
assault them elsewhere in the city.” Women are able to relax.  They don’t have
to periodically check around them to make sure they’re not being groped or
stared at. They don’t have to worry about drawing attention to themselves or
revealing too much information in earshot of possible stalkers.  They don’t have
to hear uncomfortable comments. Many women prefer these cars because
they decrease the risk of sexual assault. Many men also like it because it eases
their fear of being falsely accused of harassment.

However, many men do not respect segregated cars.  In India and Brazil, it is
common for groups of men to ride illegally in women-only cars.  Women are too
afraid to protest. When a woman told a man to leave a women-only car in Brazil,
he flipped her off and became aggressive.  He had to be restrained.

I believe women-only cars are necessary to reduce sexual harassment on
public transportation.  Considering ¼ of women in Nepal have been sexually
harassed on public transportation, something obviously needs to be done, and
I think women-only cars are a great start.


However, we need to mindful of its effects on victim-blaming.  Now, if a woman
is groped on the train but it’s not a women-only car, people ask, “Why wasn’t
she in the women-only car if she didn’t want to be harassed?”  It’s almost as
if men see women not in the women-only car as an invitation.

It’s also only a temporary solution.  Society can’t only protect them during their
commute.  What about street harassment? Here in the Bay area, I have been
whistled at and men have called, “Legs, legs, legs!”  What about harassment at
work? Sixty percent of women have experienced sexual harassment in the
workplace.

We need to start working on a real solution.  We need to foster a supportive
environment where women will not feel judged if they report their harassment.
We need to continue the empowerment of the Me Too movement worldwide.
This way, we can expose harassers, and they can realize their actions have
consequences.  Women shouldn’t have to be constantly forced to take
measures to protect ourselves. It’s them that need to change.

Sources:


Adam W. Purinton

Adam W. Purinton, was sentenced for life in prison for the shooting and killing of an innocent man, he had also shot at 2 other men who ende...