Friday, December 13, 2019

Was Justice Achieved in the Carter v. Massachusetts Case?

If I were to determine whether justice was achieved in this case, I would lean towards yes. I believe that just behavior/treatment was given to Michelle Carter. Although she did not physically force Conrad into the truck, Michelle had a considerable amount of influence over him and Conrad had a history of suicide attempts, which makes her case difficult to judge. Evidently, Michelle was nowhere near a mentally healthy state.  Michelle was struggling with her own issues: a severe eating disorder, isolation, lack of attention, suicidal thoughts, and serious self harm. Both Conrad and Michelle were on psychiatric drugs which had side effects of increased risk of suicidal ideation, behavior, and impulsivity. Conrad even told Michelle that there was nothing that she could do to prevent him from dying. Under this circumstance, Michelle’s logic led her to believe that if there was nothing that she could do to prevent him from dying, then maybe she should try to support what he wants by helping him to die. Michelle had countless issues going on in her life which show that she was not in her right mind. This kind of logic is not rational from the standpoint of a mentally person, but she was not mentally healthy. She also had an extreme obsession with the TV show, Glee; she also acted as if both cases were the same by saying lines verbatim to Conrad. She was unable to differentiate fantasy from reality, so it is questionable whether she was able to understand the consequences of anything she was doing. On the other hand, there is still some evidence that she knew that what she was doing was wrong. Michelle texted Sam Boardman that she “could have saved him, but didn’t.” She also texted a friend that she had sex with Conrad. These texts point to her personal issue of a lack of attention. If she knew that this incident would spark people to comfort her, thereby giving her attention, then it shows that she has some ability to reason that she could have done something to save him, and that she has a motive to not save him. In court, the judge believed that beyond a reasonable doubt, the actions Michelle Carter constituted wanton and reckless behavior which killed him. Conrad was struggling with his issues and had everything secured for the suicide attempt however, he broke that chain of self causation by taking himself out of the vehicle. When Michelle realized that he exited the truck, she instructed him to get back in the truck where she knew that it became a toxic environment unsuitable to human life. I agree that she did engage in wanton and reckless conduct, and that 2 and a half years of prison was appropriate for her crime.



Los Altos Jewelry Store Robbing

     
Image result for los altos store robbing


        On December 2nd, a Los Altos jewelry store in downtown Los altos called Marcel Jewelry design was robbed. A truck broke through the front of the building and they crashed the front the wall of the store. The thieves stole an estimate of $200,000 worth of jewelry from the display case. The thieves used hammers to smash the display cases, grabbing as much jewelry as they could and then ran out in about 60 seconds. This is not the first time that the store has been hit, in fact, it has been robbed 3 times in the past few months. The past 2 times that someone has tried to rob the store they have been unsuccessful and this is the first time in 42 years that thieves have been successful in robbing the store. In the past, there have been other jewelry stores that have been broken into, and it causes a big mess. The owner said, "I see a big mess that I need to clean up and a lot of money to fix the windows and everything."
        Other people gave their input and talked about, how this is not the first time a break-in has happened in downtown Los Altos that was successful. Another jewelry store had a whole safe taken from them in Downtown Los Altos and the alarm didn't even go off. People now have their concerns and feel like the Los Altos Police Department isn't doing enough to keep them safe. They talk about how this has now become a reoccurring event, and how it is only going to keep getting worse and worse if no actions are taken to stop it.



https://abc7news.com/video-truck-slams-through-bay-area-jewelry-store-during-burglary/5731932/

Strange federal crimes

18 U.S.C. §1657: It's illegal to consult with a known pirate.

21 USC §333 & 21 CFR §102.39: It's a crime to sell onion rings resembling normal onion rings but made from diced onion, without saying so.

27 USC §§205, 207 & 27 CFR §4.64(a)(8): It's a federal crime to advertise wine in a manner that suggests it has intoxicating qualities.(That's right - it's illegal NOT to false advertise)

15 U.S.C. §§330a & 330d: Attempting to change the weather without telling the Secretary of Commerce is illegal.

18 U.S.C. §1857: It's a crime to knowingly let your pig enter a fenced-in area on public land where it might destroy the grass.(May have been important a couple centuries ago.)

All of this just goes to show how obsolete some laws have become as the world has developed. What lawmakers from the early stages of the US found important and relevant to society are not necessarily useful, sometimes even detrimental, to what is important today.

Trump's Twitter Statistics

Donald J. Trump as tweeted a grand total of 47,085 times. Since his presidency, he has tweeted 13,123 times(A lot less than I expected, considering the total number of times). Trump's record for most tweets in a day is 123, mostly comprised of republican retweets over the impeachment hearings.

He currently has approaching 67,500,000 followers, but his estimated amount of fake followers is roughly 61%, around double that of other political figures. 72% of his followers have also been inactive for over 120 days.

My conclusion: There are a lot of bots on Twitter - Trump just has an abnormally large number of them. How much does this actually affect Trump and other political figures? I have no idea.

Another Michelle Carter

Inyoung You, is a 21 year old woman who was charged with involuntary manslaughter. It was revealed that she had sent several abusive texts such as "FUCK YOU GO KILL YOURSELF.." to her boyfriend, who later killed himself on May 20th. It was also said that You was abusive, mentally, physically and psychologically. You's defense was also that she was mentally fragile herself. Just like the Michelle Carter case we learned about earlier in the semester.


Supremacists v. Progressives

iZombie
  • 4 years after the zombie outbreak, humans are mad at zombies for taking over Seattle and creating more and more of themselves
  • One human in particular forms a gang called the Deadenders whose goal is to kill all the zombies
  • in retaliation the zombies go rouge and take matters into their own hands by putting zombies in high positions of power outside of Seattle to protect themselves
  • Soon domestic terrorist attacks start happening and a civil war breaks out between the zombies and humans
This puts a twist on the classic white supremacist versus progressive citizen of our world. We learned about the Supremacist who committed acts of domestic terrorism inspired by a book, The Turner Diaries. And just as the Zombies retaliated and the Humans fought thus resulting in a civil war, we too have had a civil war due to differences in appearance. Our civil war was against the north and south over the enslavement of black citizens, which is still a highly controversial topic in America today. Although not indefinite to all Supremacists, the civil war and its topic of slavery is still the basis to their need for power. Some white supremacists feel it is the white man's place to rule the world and have anyone who doesn't look like them, serve them. Not to say that Humans wanted Zombies to be their slaves but they definitely wanted to eradicate them because of the "danger" they imposed. And that is still a very common thought for white supremacists. Some feel that if they allow for minorities to reach high places of power or be treated equally then they will somehow be replaced and forgotten. No one wants to be replaced but that is no justification on how we treat other people or even the matter of the truth. There is no truth to this allegation, in the fictional world or non-fictional world. Both sides decided it was violence that was going to save them when in reality it just divided them further instead of reaching a consensus. 10 years after the civil war broke loose between the zombies and humans, it was decided that there would be an island specifically inhabited by zombies. Although not the solution since there were still Deadenders who wanted them eradicated and in fact divided them even more by admitting that they were not to be living on the same continent as the humans implying that they are too dangerous. 

in conclusion, there wasn't a solution found in this fictional show and clearly there hasn't been a solution found in our real world because there are still people who feel that if there isn't segregation then they will never have the power they think they deserve. 



Race and Police Brutality

Image result for oscar grant shootingOakland, California - It was the early hours of 2009 New Year's Day. Oscar Grant, an African American father of a 4 year old girl, was on his way back from a New Year's celebration at 2:00 am. A fight broke out along the BART train which caused the police to be called to the Fruitvale Station. Officer Johannes Mehserle and officer Anthony Pirone responded to the call. Officer Pirone used offensive and aggressive language to pull the men off the train. Through all the insults and the abuse, Oscar Grant stayed calm and told his friends to stay cool and cooperate. That was not enough to save him from what was to come. A series of events instigated by Officer Pirone's hostile behavior led to the officers assaulting Grant. Pirone punched and kneed him, Grant was pushed down and Pirone kneed him in the face and finally, Officer Mehserle pulled out his gun and shot him in the back.

This incident created anger and protests among the black community. It was one of the first shootings to have been filmed and shown to the world. Grant's cooperative and calm behavior showed that the shooting was completely unprovoked and uncalled for. The racial slurs and offensive language used by officer Pirone caused the events to escalate and lead to unnecessary police brutality. This was a crime that had happened before and had happened often but this one was filmed for the whole world to see.

A similar case of police brutality was that of Michael Brown. Both cases demonstrated an unprovoked act by the police towards black men and both created an outcry by the black community. The unfortunate killing of Brown and Grant at the hands of a white police officer were both blamed on racial motives. 

Source: https://www.kqed.org/news/11744106/bart-releases-report-with-new-details-of-officers-roles-in-oscar-grant-killing



Adam W. Purinton

Adam W. Purinton, was sentenced for life in prison for the shooting and killing of an innocent man, he had also shot at 2 other men who ende...