Tuesday, December 3, 2019

Does sleep help eyewitnesses memory?

It’s always been a common belief that sleep is involved in strengthening memories. Researchers David Morgan; PhD student, Laura Mickes; senior author at University of Bristol, and other researchers.from Royal Holloway tested this theory. By conducting a large-scale online experiment with 4,000 participants, they measured the impact of sleep on eyewitness identification accuracy on experimental eyewitnesses. Half of the participants watched a video of a mock crime and went to sleep, while the other half stayed awake. They were all tested 12 hours after watching the video on their memory for the perpetrator in the video during a line-up.

Laura Mickes said, “based on prior work that sleep improves memory, we predicted that it would in this case too. It did not. There was no difference in memory performance between the sleep and wake groups.” In other words, sleeping does not benefit eyewitness identification accuracy because both participants who slept and stayed awake were equally likely to determine innocent from guilty suspects. Their research shows that if a suspect was identified with high confidence, they were more likely to be accurate than if the suspect was identified with low confidence.

So what does this mean for the criminal justice system today? My understanding is that police should not tell victims of crimes or bystanders to “sleep it off to refresh their memory” because it won’t help them. However, if the eyewitness is confident with their answer then it should be more trustworthy than someone who is less confident with their selection from a lineup. This is probably already known, but having an extra study to prove the psychology behind confidence should be assuring to crime investigators.


Sources:
https://medicalxpress.com/news/2019-12-memory-eyewitnesses.html

Aniah Blanchard

Late on October 23, 2019, nineteen-year-old Aniah Blanchard was seen at a Chevron gas station in Auburn, Alabama - this was the last time Aniah would be seen alive. Just before midnight, Aniah's roommate received several Snapchats displaying Aniah with a young man. Aniah's Mom, Angela Harris, said that Aniah's debit card was used the night of her disappearance and her phone went dark after 11:57pm. Aniah's family reported her missing the next day. After Aniah went missing, pleas made by Aniah's stepfather, UFC heavyweight Walt Harris, made national headlines. As a result, police launched a full-scale investigation into Aniah's disappearance. Two days after Blanchard disappeared, police found Blanchard’s black 2017 Honda CR-V more than 50 miles away from Auburn in Montgomery, Alabama. The vehicle was discovered with deep dents, paint scraped off the passenger side, and Blanchard's blood-splattered inside. On November 25, 2019, police found Blanchard's body in the woods near Highway 80 in Macon county. A medical examiner confirmed the identity of the victim and the cause of death as a gunshot wound. Three men have been charged in relation to Aniah's disappearance and death. Ibraheem Yazeed, 29, and Antwain Fisher, 35, have been charged with first-degree kidnapping while David Johnson Jr. has been charged with hindering prosecution.  Fisher allegedly threw out evidence and gave Yazeed a ride after Blanchard’s death. Johnson allegedly misled police about his son’s role in driving Yazeed to Florida after Blanchard's death. Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty for Yazeed who supposedly kidnapped Blanchard from the gas station and then fatally shot her. On December 2, 2019, County District Attorney Brandon Hughes announced a capital murder charge against Yazeed. After being arrested on a kidnapping charge, Yazeed has been held without bond since November 7, 2019. Yazeed was identified using surveillance footage from the gas station where Aniah was last seen. A witness also told police that he saw someone force Blanchard into a car and then drive away from the gas station: Yazeed matched this witness description.

Image result for ANIAH BLANCHARD KIDNAPPER

https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2019/12/03/aniah-blanchard-murdered-stepdaughter-ufc-fighter/
https://www.nbcnews.com/news/crime-courts/remains-alabama-confirmed-be-those-aniah-blanchard-n1092921

Homelessness knotted in mental illness

Our beloved city of San Fransisco is home to approximately 7,000 homeless residents. We watch them make a house of the streets, in the cold as they argue with the voices in their head. According to a 2015 assessment by the Department of Housing and Urban development, 564,708 found themselves sleeping on the street on a given night in the United States. 25% of those people were diagnosed as seriously mentally ill, and 45% were diagnosed with any mental illness. Mental Illness not understood, or not dealt with through coping mechanisms leads to cognitive and behavioral problems that makes it difficult to to earn a stable income and be able to carry out stable housing. The combination of mental illness and homelessness can lead to other factors including increased alcohol consumption and drug abuse. Un dealt with mental illness can cause the person to try and self medicate using drugs, because seeking medical attention can cost too much. Studies show that the traumatic event of getting thrown into the street heavily influences a persons symptoms of mental illness. It relates to higher levels of psychiatric stress, higher levels of drug abuse, and a lower perceived rate of recovery. There are more people with untreated severe psychiatric illnesses living on the streets then there are receiving care in hospitals. In relation,"Dumping patients out of hospitals and into the streets may save the health system money, but increases overall cost to taxpayers by shifting care to more expensive jails and prisons." Homelessness also increases their chances of coming in contact with the law. Putting people away to shield the publics eyes solves nothing and is never the solution. The streets are incredibly unsafe, especially with someone in such a vulnerable state. A 1988 report on homeless women in San Fransisco noted that women were being assaulted at a petrifying rate, with some women being raped as many as 17 times. To protect themselves, homeless women were known to wear 10 pairs of panty hose at once and bundle up in layers of clothing. Those who are visibly mentally ill are easy marks for thieves and criminals. Those that are psychotic are significantly more likely to be robbed, beaten, injured, and/or threatened with a weapon. Albert Blanchard, a homeless man from Nashville with a long history of schizophrenia and homelessness was set on fire as he slept on the sidewalk. His sister was noted saying " Alberts paranoia would not allow him to stay in one place for long. He chose to live in the streets to keep the people the voices warned him of from finding him." Albert spent more than 6 months in the hospital and had 8 separate surgeries as a result of the attack. This goes to show a backlight on the issue of homelessness. Not everyone can provide stability for themselves, and for some it can't be left up to them to do so.

The impact money has in the criminal justice system

 The criminal justice system does not function in the same way for the rich and the poor. As we saw in OJ Simpson's case earlier this semester, OJ was able to use his money and fame to hire the best attorney's and essentially get a free pass from even the police when they would show up to his house from abuse calls. OJ certainly would have had no chance if he was an average African American man. 
  Currently, more than 60% of people in US prisons are racial and ethnic minorities, and the majority of them are poor. Theoretically, the law is race-neutral and class-neutral. However, that simply isn't the case. While the upper class and lower class use drugs are roughly the same rates, one who is a part of the lower class is much more likely to be put behind bars. Drug law enforcement is told to focus on certain low-income communities of color.
  According to an expert by the name of Marc Mauer, the wealthy are not exploiting the system, but they are able to take advantage of the rights they can afford. They can pay bail, hire capable defense counsels, and they are overall in a much better position to set themselves free. Statistically speaking, one may argue that the lower class is more inclined to commit crimes. However, I believe that there should be no advantages in the justice system for certain groups based on income. Rather, one should be tried and have equal opportunity to defend themselves. Too many innocent people are locked up behind bars due to not having a capable defense team.

Sources:
https://www.researchgate.net/blog/post/two-in-one-differences-in-the-us-justice-system-for-the-rich-and-the-poor

Maricela Magana Ruiz Story

Image: mugshot, Maricela Magana Ruiz

California mother, Maricela Magana Ruiz, was arrested on Monday after authorities found her 3-year-old son tied up inside a burning house with a plastic bag over his head. While firefighters in Southern California were called to Maricela's house, they found Ruiz herself, bound by her feet, in her bedroom. 

She had allegedly tied the young boy at his hands up in his bedroom, put the bag over his head, and was then booked early Monday on suspicion of child endangerment. We are unsure about the cause of the fire. Ruiz had also tied herself, but at her feet, with something similar to shoe string. They were both transferred to a local hospital to be treated for smoke inhalation. 

It wasn't clear if Magana Ruiz has a lawyer, because Jail records did not list one. However, an official with the Ventura County Jail said that Ruiz HAS been released on a $50,000 bail. 

A question that I have is, do we think it is reasonable for Ruiz to be let out on bail? I personally think that this woman, along with child endangerment issues, has mental issues as well. Perhaps Ruiz is depressed? Suicidal? I personally think that the only way that Ruiz should be released from jail is by admitting herself to a mental hospital where they can figure out the root cause for this incident. I am unaware if her son has been taken away, relocated, or whom he is living with, but I know for a fact it should not be his mother. 




Just Mercy

  In Lit Circles last year, I read Just Mercy by Bryan Stevenson, which is based on a real story. The main character, Walter McMillian is wrongly accused of murder due to his skin color. Bryan Stevenson, the Narrator, is Walter's attorney who fights with him when the whole town is against him.
  Walter was on the death row for the killing of a young woman in Alabama. Walter had an affair with a white woman, and that seemed to be the same cause of why he was accused. Walter had numerous eye-witnesses who were with him at a church fund-raiser at his home when the murder took place. The Jury was nearly all white and implemented his life sentence, but the judge fought to make it the death penalty.
  Walter had reached out to many lawyers, and the only one to take on the uphill battle was Bryan Stevenson. Bryan brought comfort to his family and worked through the long process of trying to free him. Bryan worked and proved that the State's witness had lied on the stand. Walter was locked up on death row before he was tried, but after 6 years and countless hours of work recounted by Bryan Stevenson, Walter was a free man.


Sources:
https://www.nytimes.com/1993/03/03/us/alabama-releases-man-held-on-death-row-for-six-years.html

Jeffrey Epstein Didn't Kill Himself and the Meme that Did

Jeffrey Epstein is a man who ran a child sex slave business for the very rich and well off men who wished the have sex with little girls. Epstein was caught and was due to spending time in prison. Day before he was supposed to give the names of other men who were rumored to be on his island such as Bill Clinton, while on suicide watch, Jeffrey Manged to kill himself. It is very hard to commit suicide while on suicide watch, and this the memes were born.
Image result for jeffrey epstein didnt kill himself memesImage result for jeffrey epstein didnt kill himself memesImage result for jeffrey epstein didnt kill himself memesImage result for jeffrey epstein didnt kill himself memesImage result for jeffrey epstein didnt kill himself memesImage result for jeffrey epstein didnt kill himself memes

These memes prove a point, while the mass media was busy convincing us that Jeffrey Epstein was able to commit suicide while he was under suicide watch is a joke, and we as the populous were able to call their bullshit and make a joke out of it to piss them off. The same people making these meme are to voters of tomorrow and no longer trust the mass media corporations to provide for them the truth mixed with no personal opinions.

Adam W. Purinton

Adam W. Purinton, was sentenced for life in prison for the shooting and killing of an innocent man, he had also shot at 2 other men who ende...