Monday, September 23, 2019

Did the NFL violate Colin Kaepernick's 1st amendment rights?

     In 2016, NFL Star Colin Kaepernick voiced his concerns of a recurring issue of police brutality and racial oppression going on in the United States by kneeling during the National Anthem prior to an NFL game. Kaepernick was soon boycotted by all 32 NFL teams, and essentially lost his job due to his peaceful protests. The NFL has punished Kaepernick for exercising his right to freedom of expression.



President Donald Trump has urged NFL owners to prohibit players from protesting. 2 years ago, Trump, in a campaign rally in Alabama, urged the team owners to fire any "son of a bitch" player who protested. Our president was calling for owners to boycott players who exercised their 1st amendment right to freedom of expression. In May 2018, the NFL release a new policy requiring players to stand during the National Anthem if they are out on the field. They could sit silently in the locker room, or stand for the National Anthem on the field, so they couldn't kneel to protest.
   
   Many legal experts argue that both Trump and the NFL have violated the 1st amendment rights to freedom of expression and silent protest, of all players who have kneeled during the Anthem. Marc Edelman, a law professor at City University of New York, said that "It's a very bold statement to sue the United States based upon alleged wrongdoing of the sitting president, and filing such a claim might make a player such as Colin Kaepernick into an even more polarizing figure". He also said, "However, based upon the pure black-letter law, a first amendment claim of this nature may have a reasonable chance to succeed".

Sources:

https://www.huffpost.com/entry/kaepernick-trump-first-amendment-nfl-national-anthem_n_5b15b680e4b093ac33a0f94c

https://constitutioncenter.org/blog/the-first-amendment-and-restricting-professional-athlete-protests

Sunday, September 22, 2019

Cannibal Cop or Horror Novelist?



“Thought Crimes: The Case of the Cannibal Cop” showed us the story and trial of Gilberto Valle, a former police officer for the NYPD. With the given nickname of “cannibal cop” by the media outlets, we would expect Valle to have an unsuccessful future and would only be thought of as a criminal. However, Valle took his fantasies and used them as inspiration for horror novels after his memoir received positive feedback. His first novel, A Gathering of Evil only goes further into the depth of Valle’s fantasies of kidnapping and cannibalism through a sadist group that preys on young women. Valle’s most recent book, The Social Catalogue of #Prey (sequel to A Gathering of Evil) was published this past year in 2019. The continuation of his first book also ties in the danger of social media and the value of privacy. Valle’s books have become recognized all over social media and seem to have a following of fans. Many praise his writing saying, “Nothing shows a horror book succeeding more than when it actually horrifies you”. He defines his fantasies as a “sexual fetish” and “it is something that [he] didn’t choose, and it’s something that [he] lives with and that [he] is fine with”. Valle knows that his novel is not for everyone and is very disturbing for those who do not feel the same way. 

GIlberto Valle

Valle also went to the 2019 CrimeCon in New Orleans. During the conference, he talked about the mistakes he made, the chatroom and how it ruined his marriage. Valle had actually fought to gain custody of his daughter but gave up due to the legal fees. He revealed, “he is ashamed of it all” but defends himself still asking the question, “is not liking me reason enough to have me in prison for the rest of my life?”. Valle’s question relates to the concept of thought crimes, and whether they should be prosecuted without action taken after them. Along with writing his horror novels, Valle works at his friend’s construction company and believes that in the future, he won’t be defined by his mistakes.
Sources:

Football, Free Speech, and Trump Signs

North Stanly High School cheerleaders in North Carolina held up a “Trump 2020” sign at a football game last month.  This violates a school policy that prohibits political material shown in school publications or at school events.  

Image result for cheerleaders trump sign

After a photo of the political display was posted on Facebook, the North Carolina High School Athletic Association put them on “probation” for one year, claiming the display violated their handbook.  However, “probation” is not clearly defined, and the squad is still allowed to cheer. They just were warned not to raise the flag again, as there could be fines or suspensions.

Many took to social media to post in support of the cheerleaders’ 1st amendment right to free speech.  One community member explained, “It is their right as young adults to support whomever they want. I understand this is a football game, but as long as they don't interrupt the game... I don't see an issue with the banner."  Even Representative Richard Hudson (R - NC) tweeted in support of the girls, “As Stanly Co's Congressman, I am concerned our students are being punished for exercising their First Amendment right to free speech.” 

A spokesperson from the school clarified that this policy doesn’t oppose the 1st Amendment because the students represent the school.  Displaying political material could be interpreted as the school endorsing that campaign.

However, right-wing publications took it further.  They were outraged about the “probation,” and even spread false reports that the cheerleaders were banned from football games.  Supporters of the cheerleaders planned a rally outside the football field before the September 20th game. One of the organizers was also a supporter of Proud boys, a right-wing extremist group that partakes in violent protests.

Image result for proud boys rally

Because of the rally and fears it could become violent, the school postponed the football game until the next day.  They also stated only signs with the school logo would be allowed at the game and that there would be extra police and safety measures, like bag checks and metal detectors.

Thankfully, the rally was peaceful, and the football game ended up being a “routine football game.”  The only sign was the banner the team ran through.

This incident raises the debate about the extent to free speech in public schools.  In Tinker v. Des Moines (1969), the court ruled students do not lose their right to freedom of speech and expression at school.  They found students are allowed to express their political opinions, such as by wearing armbands, as long as it’s not disruptive.  This ruling would protect the cheerleaders displaying a Trump sign.

Image result for tinker v des moines

However, Hazelwood v. Kuhlmeier (1988) contradicts this earlier ruling.  In this case, the court ruled schools don’t have to promote student speech that doesn’t conform to their values.  Since North Stanly High School didn’t want to be political, this ruling states it was constitutional for them to restrict the cheerleaders’ 1st Amendment right.  If this case were to go to court, the school would be able to cite Hazelwood v. Kuhlmeier (1988). Looking at the history of these types of cases, the school would likely win.

Sources:


Friday, September 20, 2019

Cannibalism

Gilberto Valle (Cannibal Cop) didn't actually act on the chats that he had sent about kidnapping and possibly eating women. Although the chats were disgusiting and hard to read, it was all a fantasy to him, which is why he shouldn't get a huge punishment.

However, many serial killers act on cannibalism. For instance, a guy named Jeffrey Dahmer was arrested for the killing and eating of 17 males. Dahmer lured these men to his house by promising money or sex, before strangling them to death. After they were dead, he engaged in sex acts with their bodys and kept body parts and photos as souvenirs. With the last 13 bodies, he began to keep their body parts in the fridge and would eat at their flesh. After getting arrested multiple times, he was finally sentenced to 16 consecutive life terms in prison.

In addition, there was evidence that Valle had thought about kidnapping and killing women, but he claims that it was a fantasy. There was no further evidence that he went through with what he said he was going to do. This follwed his first amendment, free speech, because he has the right to think and say what he wants, as long as it isn't affecting others. I do believe that he deserved some kind of punishment, which he got, because he still engaged in these websites and had the conspiracy of kidnapping. On the other hand, not only did Dahmer have these disgusting thoughts, but he also acted on them. Doctors claim that he was "sane" and knew what he was doing when he murdered these men. This went on for 13 years, so he definitley got the punishment that he deserved. Especially after getting away with smaller crimes that he performed earlier in his life. He went further than his first amendment, by harming other innocent people. I also believe he deserved to die because he harmed so many people in his lifetime and after his 16 years in prison, he was probably going to go out and murder more people.


https://www.biography.com/crime-figure/jeffrey-dahmer

Child Trafficking In Mountain View

I remember as a young girl, I never worried about being kidnapped against my will, and sold on the black market as a part of a large scale sex trafficking business.  Of course, my parents warned me to never talk to strangers because they could leur me in with things like candy and take me away forever. Although I knew these things  I grew up believing that child trafficking only happened in faraway places, where the poverty and crime rates were unproportionally high. Only until fairly recently I had this mindset- thinking that silicon valley was a safe place. The last thing I would've expected to hear was sex trafficking was happening in the city right next to mine. Once I heard people were caught sex trafficking in Mountain View, my whole perspective changed. It's not something that we can just ignore, for it could happen to any of us.

Brother and sister in Mountain View were arrested by the police for bringing Guatemalan families and minors to the United States for forced labor and sexual slavery. Detectives in this case are still looking for additional victims of human trafficking by these siblings. Carlos Garza, 33, and Evelia De Maria Galvez, 41, were arrested on Dec. 20 without incident. Garza is now being suspected of multiple counts of human trafficking. Whereas, Galvez is suspected of being an accessory to this crime. Garza also goes by the names Gabino Galvez and Mynor Tobar.

Many people were affected by this brother and sister. Even after they found some of the victims police still are suspecting multiple are yet to be identified. They're asking anyone who may be a victim of Garza or Galvez to come forward with whatever they have. Please, if anyone knows of someone who went missing around this time- even if you don't think its anything, contact 650-903-6300 to share what you know.

Source:
mercurynews.com/2018/12/28/mountain-view-siblings-arrested-suspected-of-human-trafficking/

Thursday, September 19, 2019

White privilege

I remember from a young age my parents ingrained in me the harsh realities of systemic racism. I knew if the police were to pull me over to pull over into a well lit area, and to keep both hands on the wheel at all times. I knew to call a loved one and to keep them on the phone just in case. I knew to narrate my actions to the officer before doing them, and to always move slowly and carefully. Entering into only elementary school, although unaware of the concept of systematic racism I could still see it play out in front of me. I noticed how when talking about the police, my white friends were not given warnings or instructions on how to handle the situation. I noticed how their voices didn't shake with the weight of the same fear I held.  It only began to add up to me as I grew older and continued to see discrepancies between me and my white peers, and began to educate myself. Lucky for you white people, you don't have the same things on your mind as we do.  You will never have to worry like we do of becoming a victim of law enforcement or the system itself. As we have seen happen to our uncles, cousins, friends, or brothers. You will never know what its like to be the statistics you read. It means you never have to worry about how your hair, skin color, or how your cultural accessories could be negatively perceived. White privilege means you get the privilege of living your life unaware, and unbothered simply because of the color of your skin. Its because these things don't directly effect you the same way they do us that you get to live your life ignorantly turning a blind eye. THAT is your privilege.

Banned Books: 1984

Image result for 1984In our nation's history, many books have been banned for a variety of reasons. Banned books similar to the Canibal Cop documentary have sparked a debate about thought crimes. One of the most famous banned books is George Orwell's 1984.

The book has been repeatedly banned for it's sexual and political content. Additionally, the book was challenged in court by, Jackson County, Florida, for being pro-communism.

But what made this book so bad? Well, it is set in a dystopian 1984 where the world is run by three huge governments. The government called "big brother" watches your every move. The main character realizes the government is bad and wants to rebel. He is afraid however of the thought police which looks for people who think bad things about the government. This is ironic because the book was later banned as a thought crime so to speak. The novel also contains some sexual content and most agree today that there is nothing wrong with novel and it should not have been banned.

Image result for harry potter 1
Another book that has been banned is Harry Potter. Catholic schools in Nashville banned it for depictions of witchcraft and wizardry. According to one pastor, the spells in the book are real and reading them could conjure evil spirits. This, however, did not stop the soaring sails of the novels in 2015.

In the end, banning each book only increased its popularity. Similarly, when someone on the internet may take down an embarrassing video it only gets saved and shared even more. If we want to sensor a book but banning it only increases its demand what is a better solution?


https://study.com/academy/lesson/george-orwells-1984-summary-characters-themes-analysis.html
https://www.dorrancepublishing.com/censored-story-five-banned-books/
http://www.bannedlibrary.com/podcast/2016/12/28/nineteen-eighty-four-1984-by-george-orwell
https://www.forbes.com/sites/lisettevoytko/2019/09/03/catholic-school-bans-harry-potterbut-according-to-free-speech-advocates-its-nothing-new/#6cbda31b7250

Adam W. Purinton

Adam W. Purinton, was sentenced for life in prison for the shooting and killing of an innocent man, he had also shot at 2 other men who ende...